The Exchange Hotel, Port Melbourne: Pub Classics at a Bay Street Address First Licensed in 1856

The Exchange Hotel at 39 Bay Street, Port Melbourne, has more than a familiar pub menu behind its name. Its own history traces the licence to 1856, when it was the United States Hotel, and links its early life to the sailors and stevedores of a working port. Today the address combines a bar, restaurant and function spaces, with pub classics still central to the food.

The dates behind the façade

The hotel's account places the change to the Exchange name in 1872. A significant expansion followed in 1916, giving the building its present form; the name and date remain part of the façade. Those dates describe different stages of the pub, rather than one uninterrupted version of the building or its operation.

There was another name along the way. The hotel's history recalls a period as Molly Blooms, an Irish pub in the 1980s, before the Exchange name returned in 2006. The story is one of adaptation as much as survival: a venue associated with maritime workers becoming a neighbourhood meeting place with several ways to gather.

For someone coming simply for lunch, the history need not turn the visit into a heritage tour. It gives a little context to the address and the building around the table. The present business still has an everyday role, whether the plan is a meal, a catch-up or a celebration upstairs.

Familiar dishes, with more than one direction

The November food menu puts recognisable pub food alongside seasonal mains. Chicken parma comes with Napoli sauce, smoked ham, mozzarella, lemon pepper fries and house salad. There is also an eggplant parma, while the chicken schnitzel keeps to lemon, gravy, fries and salad. The choices make it possible for a table to stay within the pub-classic tradition without everyone ordering the same plate.

Pies have their own place. Beef and Guinness pie is served with mash, greens and gravy; a fish pie combines seasonal fish, prawn, mussel, leek and cream. Sausage and mash uses pork and fennel sausages with onion gravy. These are substantial, familiar formats, described on the published menu rather than borrowed from customer recollections.

The broader list includes barramundi with white bean ragù and roasted leeks, beef cheek with ricotta gnocchi, and seafood linguine with mussels, prawns, calamari and seasonal fish. The kitchen describes its approach as contemporary Australian and British-inspired, with a seasonal menu. Check the current version before making a trip for one particular dish.

Sharing and something sweet

For a smaller start, the sharing section lists grilled halloumi with figs and honey thyme, salt and pepper calamari, and chorizo and manchego croquettes. Homemade pork sausage rolls come with tomato relish. The selection allows a meal to begin with something for the table rather than moving straight to a main course.

A warm root salad pairs roast vegetables with sweet potato crisp, pumpkin seeds and beetroot hummus. The roast cauliflower salad includes buckwheat, kale, golden raisins, sunflower seeds and goat cheese. Dessert choices include sticky toffee pudding with vanilla ice cream and butterscotch sauce, or a dark chocolate torte with berry sorbet.

Dietary markings need careful reading. The menu uses low-gluten and low-dairy labels, along with vegetarian and vegan indicators and options. It also warns that trace allergens may be present. Tell staff about allergies or intolerances when booking and ordering, rather than treating a symbol as a guarantee. The venue is licensed.

Three different gathering spaces

The functions page identifies the Dining Room, Upstairs and the Lounge. The Dining Room sits beside the main bar and is described as an open-plan setting that retains the atmosphere of the venue. The Lounge offers a semi-private area with couch seating and an open gas fireplace.

Upstairs has a private bar, lounge nooks, a convertible dance floor and an adjoining outdoor area. The hotel presents it for seated dinners, cocktail-style gatherings and celebrations, as well as business events using audiovisual facilities, whiteboards and flipcharts. The practical choice depends on the event: privacy, furniture layout and access are different questions from the total number of guests.

Discuss the intended format with the functions team and arrange a site visit if the room matters to the occasion. The website's list of possible uses is not a promise that every layout will suit every booking.

Why locals come back

According to local reviews, friendly staff and well-executed pub food are recurring reasons for a return visit. Other diners describe long waits or inconsistent meals, so the feedback is mixed rather than uniformly glowing. For a larger table, agreeing on the booking details and allowing time for the meal is sensible.

The hotel's appeal is broad: a traditional main, a different choice for another diner and spaces that can accommodate more than an ordinary lunch. Its long history is part of the setting, but the current experience still depends on what arrives at the table and how the gathering is looked after.

Before you go

Check both trading and kitchen hours; they are not identical. The hotel's FAQ says children may attend with a parent or legal guardian while the kitchen is open, and dogs are welcome outdoors and in certain indoor areas. Seating requests are considered but not guaranteed.

An important limitation is explicit: the venue says it does not have wheelchair access. Contact the team before planning a visit where access is essential. Side-street parking is described as a mix of time limits, so read the signs rather than assuming a space lasts all afternoon. Choose the room, check the details and settle in for the pub meal you came for.

Visit The Exchange Hotel
Address: 39 Bay Street, Port Melbourne VIC 3207
Phone: (03) 9810 0058
Hours: Mon–Thu noon–10.30pm; Fri noon–midnight; Sat 11am–midnight; Sun 11am–10.30pm. Kitchen: Mon–Thu noon–9pm; Fri noon–9.30pm; Sat 11am–9.30pm; Sun 11am–9pm. Check holiday variations.
Website: https://theexchangehotel.net.au/
Email: info@theexchangehotel.net.au
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/exchangeportmelb/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/theexchangeportmelbourne
Good to know: Venue FAQ states no wheelchair access. Children with parent or legal guardian while kitchen open. Confirm dietary and function requirements directly.

SHOUT US A COFFEE

If you like our work, why not shout us a coffee? Every contribution allows us to continue to serve local businesses, local sports clubs, and local community groups. It also helps us get kids into positive and healthy junior sport through our parent company BMBA Basketball Pty Ltd, where all funds are directed.

Support us so we can support our local communities. Buy us a coffee today!

The Community Forum – Our Services for your business

Website

Design

Social Media

Sales Funnel

Landing Pages

Email Marketing

Feature Articles

Video Promos

Your Page

Advertising

About the Author

Isla Morgan
Isla Morgan covers local businesses and community groups across the City of Port Phillip for The Community Forum.