Cutler & Co., Fitzroy: A Former Metal Works on Gertrude Street, Set for Dinner

On Gertrude Street, Cutler & Co. at 55–57 Gertrude Street, Fitzroy occupies a building with an industrial past and a long restaurant present. Andrew McConnell opened Cutler in 2009 in a former metal works factory, according to the restaurant's own account. Behind its glass façade, the business says, that frontage has reflected more than sixteen years of change around it.

The restaurant describes an ethos of refined, simple and hospitable dining, and says that ethos has remained constant while its cooking and the way people choose to eat have evolved. A visit can take more than one form. The website invites guests to walk in for a bite and a drink at the bar, or to reserve a table in the dining room.


Photo: Harvard Wang, courtesy of Cutler & Co.

A factory building with room to change

Cutler's photographs show a room shaped by its former life: high windows, exposed brick, metal framing and a long view through the space. Greenery, white tablecloths and low lamps soften the industrial lines. The pictures give a sense of a restaurant that keeps the building visible rather than covering it with a new identity.

The restaurant frames its own history as one of evolution rather than reinvention. It says its character comes from reflecting and embracing both neighbourhood and city. That is a modest claim for a long-running Gertrude Street business, and it avoids presenting the restaurant as unchanged since the day it opened.

For a first-time visitor, the layout offers a useful choice. The bar suits a less formal visit, while the dining room is the place for a booked meal. The restaurant's events material also describes a mezzanine, an open kitchen and a separately partitioned private dining room, each of which adds to the picture of a larger and more varied space than the street frontage first suggests.


Photo: hdavison, courtesy of Cutler & Co.

A menu between the season and the classics

Cutler describes its menu as spontaneous, thoughtful and modern, highlighting the best of the season alongside some of its best-known dishes. The current published list moves from appetisers such as house-made focaccia, breakfast radishes with almond skordalia, and beef-and-anchovy toast to the restaurant's donuts with crème fraîche, chives and Yarra Valley salmon roe.

Seafood includes rock oysters with mignonette and hot sauce, tuna crudo with mandarin vinaigrette and Ballina pipis with wild garlic and crème fraîche. Entrées listed include Long Paddock curd with cucumber and bullhorn peppers, and wood-grilled Corner Inlet calamari with green harissa and fennel. These dishes give the seasonal side of the menu a clear character.

A section headed Cutler Classics gathers dishes the restaurant clearly regards as part of its identity. A wood-grilled dry-aged rib eye with condiments and a cabbage-and-fennel salad is described as having been on the menu from day one. Roast suckling pig, a dry-aged Aylesbury duck crown with endive and medjool date, and a cheeseburger also appear in that section.

Mains, sides and dessert

Main courses on the current menu include a Comté tart with golden shimeji mushrooms, pickled walnut and soft herbs, and King George whiting with asparagus, beurre blanc and caviar. A Loddon Valley lamb dish with sheep's milk yoghurt and cumin offers another direction. Accompaniments such as butter lettuce, beans with mustard and dill, and sprouting broccoli with sage and anchovy round out a table.

Desserts include a chocolate gâteau, a rhubarb sherbet with caramelised white chocolate and buckwheat, and a floating island with almonds and salted caramel. An apple tarte Tatin with vanilla ice cream is described as one to share. A selection of cheeses offers a savoury finish instead.

As with any seasonal restaurant, these are examples from the menu published online, not a promise that each dish will be available on a particular night. Diners with allergies or dietary requirements should raise them when booking and again with staff. The restaurant's menu does not, on its own, establish how any individual dish is prepared for a specific need.


Photo: hdavison, courtesy of Cutler & Co.

Sourcing and a wine list chosen on merit

Cutler says it is committed to sourcing produce reared, grown, caught and crafted with high regard for welfare and sustainability. Its menu states that it serves only Australian seafood except where stated, and that it champions small-scale farmers and growers. The seasonal menu page names particular producers on the day, including vegetables from Ramarro Farm and calamari from Corner Inlet.

Those named producers are a snapshot rather than a permanent supplier list. They do, however, show the restaurant connecting its dishes to specific places. Guests interested in where something on the plate comes from can ask, and the menu itself often provides the starting point.

The drinks page describes a team of sommeliers who believe there is a right wine for every time and place. Cutler says its wine list includes celebrated producers and vintages, but that wines are selected on merit rather than reputation alone, with room for undiscovered future classics. The full list is published online for anyone who prefers to read before arriving.

Sundays and larger occasions

Sunday at Cutler runs as all-day dining. The restaurant describes Sunday lunch as a long-standing ritual of slowing down and coming together, anchored each month by a dish prepared by its chefs. The Sunday dish changes with the season. Through October and November 2026 it is salmon en croûte: Ōra King salmon topped with scallop mousse, wrapped in chard and puff pastry, and served with sorrel sauce for two people to share. The restaurant's journal is the place to see what is coming next.

For gatherings, the private dining room is partitioned by floor-to-ceiling metal and glass archways, which can be closed for privacy or left open to the restaurant. The business describes exposed brick, large windows and a French cheminée fireplace in that room. It lists capacity for up to 40 seated guests or 50 for a cocktail event.

The whole venue is also available for exclusive use, including the bar with its open kitchen, the main dining room and the mezzanine. Cutler lists capacity for up to 80 seated guests or 110 for a cocktail event. Events are arranged by enquiry, so dates and details should be discussed directly with the restaurant's team.

Getting there

Tram route 11 runs along Brunswick Street, and Cutler's contact page directs riders to stop 13 at the corner of Brunswick and Gertrude streets. Routes 86 and 96 both stop at the Melbourne Museum stop, at the corner of Gertrude and Nicholson streets, a short walk along Gertrude Street. The restaurant says Parliament Station is about a ten-minute walk away, and directs drivers to the secure car park at the Melbourne Museum on Nicholson Street, Carlton.

Cutler's reservations page lists opening from 5pm until late, Wednesday to Saturday, with all-day dining on Sunday from noon until late. Reservations are made through the website, while the bar welcomes walk-ins.

Book the dining room, or simply take a seat at the bar. On Gertrude Street, Cutler has been setting the table in an old factory for well over a decade.

Visit Cutler & Co.

Cutler & Co.
Address: 55–57 Gertrude Street, Fitzroy VIC 3065
Phone: (03) 9419 4888
Hours: Wednesday–Saturday from 5pm until late; Sunday from noon until late
Website: https://www.cutlerandco.com.au/
Email: info@cutlerandco.com.au
Instagram: @cutlerandco

SHOUT US A COFFEE

If you like our work, why not shout us a coffee? Every contribution allows us to continue to serve local businesses, local sports clubs, and local community groups. It also helps us get kids into positive and healthy junior sport through our parent company BMBA Basketball Pty Ltd, where all funds are directed.

Support us so we can support our local communities. Buy us a coffee today!

The Community Forum – Our Services for your business

Website

Design

Social Media

Sales Funnel

Landing Pages

Email Marketing

Feature Articles

Video Promos

Your Page

Advertising

About the Author

Maya Fitzgerald
Maya Fitzgerald covers local businesses and community groups across the City of Yarra for The Community Forum.