Fresh from the Sea: Discovering Fishi Business at Thrift Park, Mentone

In the bustling bayside suburb of Mentone, where the salty tang of Port Phillip Bay mingles with the aroma of fresh coffee from nearby cafés, lies a hidden gem that transports diners straight to the tranquil streets of Tokyo. Tucked away at 60 Florence Street, Maki Magic is more than just a sushi bar—it’s a testament to the artistry of Japanese cuisine, crafted with passion by its charismatic owner, Michael. Opened just a couple of years ago, this unassuming eatery has swiftly captured the hearts (and stomachs) of locals, earning a glowing 4.5 out of 5 rating on Tripadvisor and becoming a go-to spot for those craving authentic flavours without the pretension.

Step inside Maki Magic, and you’re enveloped in a cosy haven of warm wooden accents, subtle lantern lighting, and vibrant displays of fresh ingredients that burst with colour. The space is intimate—perfect for a quick solo lunch or a casual catch-up with friends—but don’t let its modest size fool you. Behind the counter, Michael, a sushi maestro with years of experience honed in bustling Melbourne kitchens, works his magic with the precision of a craftsman. “It’s all about balance,” he says with a grin, his hands deftly rolling rice and fish into perfect maki. “Freshness, simplicity, and a touch of joy in every bite.” Originally from a family of food enthusiasts, Michael’s journey to Mentone was inspired by a desire to bring high-quality, affordable Japanese fare to the community. What started as a dream during the quieter days of the pandemic has blossomed into a thriving local favourite, drawing in everyone from office workers seeking a speedy bento to families celebrating special occasions.

At the core of Maki Magic’s allure is its menu, a thoughtfully curated selection that celebrates the best of Japanese staples while nodding to modern twists. Sushi purists will delight in the classics: silky salmon sashimi that melts on the tongue, its buttery texture elevated by a whisper of wasabi and soy; or the signature California rolls, stuffed with crab, avocado, and cucumber for a refreshing crunch. For those with a hearty appetite, the katsu dishes steal the show—crispy chicken katsu, golden and succulent, served with a side of tangy tonkatsu sauce that begs for seconds. Bento boxes are a standout, offering compartmentalised perfection: teriyaki-glazed salmon or beef alongside sticky rice, pickled vegetables, and a generous portion of gyoza dumplings that ooze savoury filling with every bite.

Vegetarians and the health-conscious aren’t left out, either. The poke bowls are a riot of colour and nutrition, layered with quinoa or brown rice, fresh edamame, seaweed salad, and your choice of tofu or grilled veggies, all drizzled in a zesty sesame dressing. Udon soup bowls provide comforting warmth on cooler Melbourne days, brimming with springy noodles, tender prawns, and tempura veggies that add a delightful crackle. Appetisers like veggie spring rolls and tempura prawns make for ideal sharing plates, while the donburi rice bowls—think unagi eel over fluffy rice—offer a filling feast for under $20. Prices remain refreshingly wallet-friendly, with most mains hovering between $15 and $25, making it accessible for everyday indulgence rather than a rare treat.

What truly sets Maki Magic apart, however, is the sense of community it fosters. Regulars rave about Michael’s personal touch; he’ll remember your go-to order or suggest a pairing with one of their crisp Japanese green teas. Take Sarah W., a local mum who shared her delight on Uber Eats: “We tried Maki Magic for our wedding anniversary takeaway, and it was so delicious. Everything was yummy, and even our two boys devoured it all.” On Tripadvisor, reviewers echo this sentiment, praising the “exceptional freshness” and “friendly service that makes you feel like family.” One diner noted, “It’s a tiny shop off the main street, but the colourful displays and daily specials drew me in—and I haven’t looked back.” Even on busier days, the efficient team ensures orders fly out the door for delivery via DoorDash, Uber Eats, or Menulog, with no skimping on quality.

Mentone’s dining scene is eclectic, from beachside fish and chips to Italian trattorias, but Maki Magic carves out its niche with effortless authenticity. It’s the kind of place where you can pop in for a 7am brekkie roll on a weekday—perhaps a simple onigiri for the commute—or linger over a leisurely Saturday lunch until 5pm. (Note: They’re closed Sundays, giving everyone a well-deserved rest.) As bayside living evolves, with more families and professionals calling Mentone home, spots like this remind us that great food doesn’t need grandeur; it needs heart.

Whether you’re a sushi aficionado or a curious newcomer, Maki Magic promises an escape into flavourful bliss. Swing by to experience the magic for yourself—your taste buds will thank you.

Contact Details: Maki Magic 60 Florence Street Mentone, VIC 3194 Australia Phone: +61 477 233 913 Hours: Monday–Friday 7:00am–6:30pm; Saturday 9:00am–5:00pm; Closed Sunday Delivery available via Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Menulog