TOAST IT!, Malvern East: Twelve Toasted Sandwiches That Go Well Beyond Ham and Cheese

At 49–51 Waverley Road, Malvern East, TOAST IT! takes a familiar lunch and gives it a substantial menu of its own. The café's published food menu lists twelve toasted sandwiches, moving from a cheese-led Plain Payne to slow-cooked lamb, rare roast beef and pulled pork. It is a specific sort of café choice: begin with the filling, then decide what belongs alongside it.

The menu is the clearest guide to the business's offering. It names ingredients in detail, includes a separate children's selection and distinguishes vegetarian dishes from options that can be adapted. For someone deciding what to order before leaving home, those details are more useful than a broad claim about a neighbourhood favourite.

A simple beginning, then several directions

The Plain Payne combines Warrnambool vintage cheddar, club cheddar and house mozzarella with salt flakes. The Classic adds ham off the bone and tomato to cheddar and mozzarella, with Kewpie mayonnaise and Dijon mustard. Both sit at the familiar end of a menu that becomes more elaborate as it goes.

The Tradie is described as triple-stacked bread with cheddar, mozzarella, smoked bacon, a free-range egg and chutney. It is a distinct construction rather than simply another name for the Classic. The differences are set out on the business's own menu, allowing customers to compare ingredients rather than guess from the title.

Bread choice is also stated: sourdough or a gluten-free option. That option does not make the kitchen allergen-free. The menu explicitly warns that food cannot be prepared in a completely allergen-free environment and asks customers to tell staff about dietary concerns.

Vegetables get more than a token option

The Smashed Avo combines avocado with Danish-style fetta, chilli flakes, parsley, dill and balsamic glaze. The Roast Veggie brings together pumpkin, sweet potato, zucchini, red onion, capsicum and spinach with several cheeses. They offer quite different flavour directions within the vegetarian part of the list.

The Falafel includes roasted carrots, beetroot hommus, pumpkin hommus, dukkah, mint and spinach alongside fetta and mozzarella. It shares some ingredients with the lamb sandwich but has its own place as a meat-free option. That makes the menu more varied than a single cheese toastie standing in for every vegetarian preference.

The published key identifies vegetarian, vegan-option and gluten-free-option markings. Vegan cheese is listed as an available change for several sandwiches. Customers should still explain what they need, because a dish marked as adaptable requires the appropriate substitution rather than an assumption that the standard version is already vegan.

Lunch can take a heartier turn

The Holy Schnit combines panko chicken schnitzel with cheddar, mozzarella, parmesan, tarragon, avocado, red capsicum and Kewpie mayonnaise. The Chick Brie takes roast chicken in a different direction, pairing it with triple brie, cranberry sauce, caramelised onion and spinach.

Rare roast beef is matched with horseradish, caramelised onion and spinach as well as cheddar and mozzarella. The Lamb uses slow-cooked lamb, roasted carrots, two kinds of hommus, dukkah, mint and spinach.

The Pulled Pork includes barbecue pulled pork, apple slaw, mint, Kewpie mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, parmesan and mozzarella. Smoked salmon has its own option with cream cheese, red onion, parsley, dill, capers and rocket. The breadth is in the ingredients rather than a claim that one filling suits everyone.

A smaller menu for smaller appetites

The children's section provides basic cheese, Vegemite and Nutella choices, followed by combinations such as avocado and cheese, Vegemite and cheese, ham with cheese and tomato, and baked beans with cheese. Banana bread is also listed.

That separate selection is useful for a family comparing what different people will eat. Anyone needing highchairs, pram space or particular access arrangements should check those practicalities with the shop before visiting.

The menu also lists add-ons, including egg, ham, bacon, roast chicken, roast beef, lamb, pickles and avocado. Availability and any requested changes should be confirmed at ordering, especially where dietary requirements are involved.

Coffee, tea and a cold-drink choice

The drinks page covers white and black coffee, hot chocolate, chai, mocha and matcha, with alternative milks listed. Tea Drop teas include English breakfast, French Earl Grey, peppermint and chamomile among the named options. The selection gives non-coffee drinkers more than a single fallback.

Cold options include iced coffee, iced chocolate, iced chai and iced matcha, alongside thickshakes, juice and bottled drinks. Some iced drinks are listed with ice cream, so the ingredient details matter for anyone avoiding dairy. As with the food, the current menu and a conversation with staff should guide the final choice.

The website's location page gives the Malvern East phone number as 0493 787 997. Its general contact page separately lists a Moorabbin number, so Waverley Road visitors should use the location-specific contact. Check TOAST IT!’s website or Instagram for current Malvern East opening times before making a special trip.

TOAST IT!'s attraction is not that lunch needs to become complicated. It is that a familiar format can offer a genuine choice. Start with the filling that sounds right, then let the toastie do the rest.

Visit TOAST IT!

Address: 49–51 Waverley Road, Malvern East VIC 3145
Phone: 0493 787 997
Hours: Check TOAST IT!’s website for current opening times.
Website: https://www.toastit.com.au/
Email: contact@toastit.com.au
Socials: Instagram https://www.instagram.com/toastitcafe/ ; Facebook https://www.facebook.com/toastitcafe

SHOUT US A COFFEE

If you like our work, why not shout us a coffee? Every contribution allows us to continue to serve local businesses, local sports clubs, and local community groups. It also helps us get kids into positive and healthy junior sport through our parent company BMBA Basketball Pty Ltd, where all funds are directed.

Support us so we can support our local communities. Buy us a coffee today!

The Community Forum – Our Services for your business

Website

Design

Social Media

Sales Funnel

Landing Pages

Email Marketing

Feature Articles

Video Promos

Your Page

Advertising

About the Author

Sienna Park
Sienna Park covers local businesses and community groups across the City of Stonnington for The Community Forum.