At 172 Koornang Road, in the heart of Carnegie's shopping strip, Lizzy's Chocolate Creations has been making chocolate since May 1983, in the same building where it first opened. Out the front is a shop of glossy pralines, gift boxes and seasonal eggs. Out the back, as the family puts it, is where it all gets made. “It's nostalgia at its finest,” the business says.
A family name on the door
Lizzy's is a family business, and the name is a family story. The shop was the original idea of Keith Van Tilburg, an accomplished patissier whom the business describes as one of Melbourne's first chocolatiers. He named it after his wife, Elizabeth. Elizabeth is no longer with the family, but, in the words of the business, “her legacy still lives on” in the name above the door.
Today Lizzy's is run by Ingrid and Tim Nichols. Ingrid is Keith and Elizabeth's daughter, and Keith passed his knowledge down to Ingrid, so the recipes and techniques have stayed in the family.
Made on site, the old-fashioned way
The chocolate is made on the premises. The shop operates in “the original dwellings of 1983”, with manufacturing at the rear of the Koornang Road premises.
The family's stated aim is to “uphold our traditional European recipes, whilst constantly evolving and sharing our creative passion for chocolate.” That balance shows in the range. There are classic handmade chocolates for those who want the flavours they grew up with, and seasonal creations for those who like a surprise.
What is behind the glass
The range on Lizzy's own website shows how wide "handmade chocolates" can stretch. At the heart of it are the filled chocolates, sold individually so customers can build their own selection. They include classic cherry liqueur, caramel and Irish cream, and a chocolate cappuccino cup. Small thimble cups and fluted dessert cups sit alongside them.
Then there are the snacking lines: solid chocolate bars, a marshmallow heart, and slabs of rocky road and honeycomb. Lizzy's also bakes. The shop lists a honeycomb brownie, a dark chocolate brownie, homemade choc chip cookies and yo-yos.
Some items are seasonal. Dutch chocolate letters have appeared on the website alongside a solid chocolate bunny for Easter and a chocolate Christmas pudding for December.
Gift boxes
Gift boxes are a core part of the business. The website lists assorted chocolate gift boxes in a smaller and a larger size, a small chocolate-filled heart and a Nougatine Book Box.
The range can also be ordered through the Lizzy's online store, with delivery available within Melbourne for anyone who cannot get to Carnegie.
Carnegie and Carlton North
Alongside the original Carnegie shop, the family now runs a second store at 641 Rathdowne Street in Carlton North, and both are listed on its website. Carnegie remains the home of the business and the place where the chocolate is made.
Why locals come back
According to local reviews, the handmade chocolates and truffles are the main reason people keep returning, and many reviewers describe Lizzy's as their first stop when they need a gift. Friendly service is a common theme, and reviewers often describe the truffles and boxed selections as gift-worthy.
The hot chocolate also gets regular mentions from reviewers. The criticisms are few. Parking along Koornang Road can be difficult at busy times, and one recent reviewer found an iced chocolate drink disappointing. Overall, reviewers describe a dependable local favourite for special occasions.
Planning a visit
Lizzy's trades six days from 9am, closing at 5:30pm from Monday to Thursday and at 6pm on Fridays. The website gives two different Saturday closing times, so check it before a Saturday visit. The shop is closed on Sundays, and the range can also be ordered online.
Visit Lizzy's Chocolate Creations
Address: 172 Koornang Road, Carnegie VIC 3163
Phone: (03) 9568 0689
Hours: Monday to Thursday 9am–5:30pm, Friday 9am–6pm, Saturday from 9am; closed Sunday; check their website for current hours
Website: lizzyschocolates.com.au
Email: Via the contact form on the website
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lizzyschocolates/
Good to know: Second store at 641 Rathdowne Street, Carlton North. Online store available.