‘A Taste of New York in Mentone’: Huff Bagelry’s Recipe for Success”

In the heart of Mentone, a charming seaside suburb in Melbourne’s southeast, Huff Bagelry stands as a beacon for bagel enthusiasts and coffee aficionados alike. This family-run gem, located at 13 Como Parade West, has carved out a niche as a beloved local haunt, blending New York-style bagel culture with Melbourne’s renowned café scene. With its fresh, chewy bagels, quality Allpress coffee, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, Huff Bagelry has become a staple for locals and visitors seeking a quick bite or a leisurely brunch.

A Family Affair with New York Roots

Huff Bagelry, with locations in both Mentone and Carnegie, draws inspiration from the iconic bagel shops of New York City. There are no pretensions here—just a focus on delivering high-quality, freshly baked bagels with a side of friendly service. The Mentone outpost, designed by studiofour, offers a spacious and modern setting compared to its cosier Carnegie counterpart, featuring a central planter box and a vibrant wall mural by local artist Graeme Rowe. The result is a relaxed yet lively atmosphere that invites customers to linger over a coffee or grab a bagel on the go.

The family behind Huff Bagelry has perfected the art of bagel-making, ensuring each one is boiled and baked daily for that authentic chewy texture and golden crust. From classic plain and sesame to adventurous garlic salt and rosemary or blueberry, the variety caters to every palate. Customers can choose from a range of fillings, from the ever-popular smoked salmon with cream cheese and capers to inventive options like chicken schnitzel with chunky tomato relish or avocado, feta, and tomato. For those with dietary preferences, gluten-free bagels and non-dairy milk alternatives, such as Milklab almond, ensure inclusivity without compromising flavour.

A Menu That Hits All the Right Spots

Huff Bagelry’s menu is a celebration of simplicity and quality. The bagels, described by regulars as “exceptional” and “ridiculously tasty,” are the stars of the show. Whether you opt for a classic like the salmon bagel—often likened to New York’s finest—or a custom creation, the freshness of the ingredients shines through. One Tripadvisor reviewer raved about the “summer brekky on a sesame bagel,” while another praised the ham, cheese, and avocado combo for its straightforward deliciousness. For those with a sweet tooth, the cinnamon and raisin bagel with Nutella or the moist, flavourful carrot cake offers a delightful treat.

The coffee, sourced from Collingwood’s Allpress Espresso, is another draw. Served in generous portions—think large ceramic mugs for lattes or flat whites that rival hot chocolates in size—it’s the perfect companion to a still-warm bagel. Reviewers consistently praise the coffee’s quality, with one calling it “the best in Mentone.” The café also offers chai lattes, hot chocolate, and craft beer, making it a versatile spot for any time of day.

A Community Hub with a Welcoming Vibe

What sets Huff Bagelry apart is its ability to balance efficiency with warmth. Despite its bustling atmosphere—often packed with locals, families, and students from nearby Kilbreda College—the service remains quick, friendly, and approachable. Staff are noted for their attentiveness, making every customer feel valued, whether they’re ordering via the SKIP app for a quick takeaway or settling in for a leisurely meal. The café’s child-friendly features, including toys and pram-friendly spacing, make it a go-to for families, while its proximity to Mentone’s railway station and shopping area adds to its accessibility.

The décor, with its clean lines, industrial touches, and thoughtful design, creates an inviting space that’s both modern and unpretentious. As one reviewer noted on Restaurant Guru, “It’s a lovely spot for a coffee and bagel in the heart of Mentone.” The open, bright layout and reasonable prices—most bagels fall between $9 and $20—make it an ideal choice for everything from a quick breakfast on the run to a relaxed Sunday lunch.

Standing Out in Mentone’s Culinary Scene

Mentone’s dining landscape is diverse, with Turkish, Italian, and vegan options aplenty, but Huff Bagelry holds its own as the suburb’s premier destination for bagels. Rated 4.0 out of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #6 of 41 restaurants in Mentone, it has earned a loyal following. Customers appreciate the consistency, with one long-time patron stating, “I’ve been going to Huff Bagelry in Mentone for years now and have never been disappointed.” Another, who drives 25 minutes to visit, calls it their “go-to place with friends and family.”

The bagelry’s commitment to quality extends beyond its food. Its use of Tripadvisor’s review collection tools reflects a dedication to engaging with customers and maintaining high standards. While some reviews mention occasional wait times or minor order errors, the overwhelming sentiment is one of satisfaction, with phrases like “excellent service,” “great atmosphere,” and “delicious bagels” appearing frequently.

A Recipe for Longevity

Since its early days, as documented in a 2015 Sweet and Sour Fork review, Huff Bagelry has grown from a hidden gem to a local institution. Its ability to adapt—offering takeaway via the SKIP app during busy periods or accommodating dietary needs—has kept it relevant in a competitive market. The Mentone location, in particular, benefits from its prime position opposite the historic 1904 Kilbreda College building, adding a touch of character to the dining experience.

For those seeking a taste of New York without leaving Melbourne, Huff Bagelry delivers. It’s a place where you can enjoy a perfectly crafted bagel, sip on top-notch coffee, Baba and soak in the vibrant yet relaxed vibe of Mentone. Whether you’re a local grabbing your usual #3 on rye or a visitor exploring the bayside, Huff Bagelry is a must-visit. As one satisfied customer put it, “Great coffee. Great bagels. Always busy, and you can see why.”