Teo’s Pizza & Bar, Highett: Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizza, a Beer Garden and Proper Neighbourhood Italian

 


 

On Railway Parade, a few steps from Highett Station, a black awning spells out the promise in coral lettering: Teo’s Wood Fired Pizza. Red-and-white umbrellas shade a little parklet behind a white picket fence. Inside, the oven is already working. That is the whole brief of this Bayside favourite — casual Italian cooking, a well-stocked bar, and a room that still feels like it belongs to the street.

Teo’s Pizza & Bar is the same family-oriented kitchen that locals knew for years as Matteo’s Pizza Parlour. The name has changed; the management, the dough and the welcome have not. There is now a second dining room in Malvern, but Highett remains the original neighbourhood room: indoor tables, on-street parklet dining, a summery beer garden, a pool table and, when the weather plays along, a gelato cart.

Google reviewers have been saying the same thing for years. One of the lines the restaurant itself is proud enough to quote is: “Advanced warning — wear comfy pants as you will not want to stop eating.” The pizzas get the headlines. Regulars often argue that the antipasti and sides are what make the table.


A 72-hour dough and a wood fire

Everything on the pizza list starts with the same slow dough. Teo’s proves its Neapolitan-style base for 72 hours. The first day lets the dough rise and fill with air; the next two days are fermentation, which builds flavour and gluten so the dough stretches without tearing. It is then opened by hand and fired in a wood oven at more than 400°C, which gives the thin centre, the blistered cornicione and that faint smoke you only get from a proper fire.

The result is lighter than a typical Australian commercial pizza and closer to the Naples style: soft in the middle, leopard-spotted at the edge, and meant to be eaten rather than photographed and forgotten.


What to order

The printed Highett menu is generous without being showy. On the red-sauce side you will find a classic Margherita with tomato, fior di latte, mozzarella, basil and parmesan (prosciutto can be added); Diavola with salami, chilli, olives and rocket; Capricciosa; Pepperoni; the hotter Piccante with pork sausage, ’nduja and red onion; a ham-and-pineapple option if that is your house rule; and a vegetable pizza finished with basil pesto.

White pizzas and house specials are where the kitchen stretches a little further. The Pumpkin pie sits on a roasted pumpkin purée with pine nuts, caramelised onion and house-made almond feta. Tartufata uses a truffle-cream base, mushrooms, San Daniele prosciutto, rocket and shaved parmesan. Matteo’s Special — still on the list after the rebrand — is stracciatella, cherry tomato, San Daniele prosciutto, parmesan and rocket. There is also a mushroom-and-potato pizza with Asiago and rosemary, a sausage-and-potato Salsiccia, and a prawn pizza with ’nduja.

Pasta is not an afterthought. Spaghetti Bolognese is a slow beef-and-pork ragù. Carbonara is the Roman version — guanciale, egg, pecorino and pepper, no cream. There is penne with porcini mushrooms, gnocchi alla Sorrentina, prawn linguine and a seafood marinara. Starters worth sharing include arancini with mushrooms, peas and Asiago; two styles of bruschetta; salt-and-pepper calamari; mussels in white-wine sugo; and a chicken cotoletta with slaw and fries. Salads are simple and sharp: Caprese, rocket-pear-parmesan, or walnut, cabbage, fennel and orange.

Gluten-free bases and vegan cheese are available for a small extra charge, and there is a short kids’ list — mini Margherita or pineapple pizza, penne, chicken and chips. Dessert runs from scoops of gelato and Teo’s tiramisu to cinnamon doughnuts and a Nutella pizza or calzone with ice cream.

Prices sit comfortably in the “$40 and under” neighbourhood-dinner bracket. A Margherita is around $22; most pizzas and pastas land in the mid-to-high twenties. Sunday carries a 10 per cent surcharge; public holidays 15 per cent. Always check the current board — the kitchen rotates specials.

 


The bar, Cheap Tuesdays and the beer garden

Teo’s is a pizza restaurant that takes the “and Bar” seriously. The list covers local and Italian beers, wine, spirits and cocktails, with the Aperol Spritz treated as a house favourite rather than a seasonal novelty. Happy Hour is a regular fixture (listings have it in the late afternoon), and Cheap Tuesdays have become a Highett habit — diners talk about a $19 pizza deal that fills the parklet and the room next door. Some locals order pizza at Teo’s and walk a few metres to Railway Wine for trivia; dogs are often part of that picture on the street.

Highett’s outdoor offering is what separates it from a standard suburban pizzeria. There is seating inside, a parklet on Railway Parade under those striped umbrellas, and a beer garden that comes into its own on warm evenings. OpenTable and the restaurant’s own copy also mention a pool table and a gelato cart — useful if you have children in tow or simply want the night to run a little longer.

The room is described, fairly, as a neighbourhood gem: good for groups, charming, casual dress, street parking, and close enough to the station that you do not need a car. It is also used for functions; the website asks you to call or email for large bookings.


Dine in, take away, or have it delivered

You can sit down, collect from the counter, or order delivery through the restaurant’s partners (Orderup is linked from the Highett page; Uber Eats and DoorDash appear on other listings). Reservations are taken through OpenTable. For a Tuesday special, a weekend lunch or a birthday table in the garden, booking is the sensible move.

Staff get consistent praise for being friendly rather than formal. That matters in a room that mixes date nights, after-work spritzes, family dinners and the odd pre-gig feed for anyone heading further into Melbourne. Reviews sit around 4.5 on Google from a few hundred diners, and higher still on OpenTable — the usual spread of “best pizza on the street” alongside the occasional note that a busy oven can run behind. That is a wood-fired kitchen on a suburban Friday, not a conveyor.


How Highett fits the map

Highett Village has quietly become one of Bayside’s better evening strips: independent kitchens, a wine bar next door, the station at the end of the street. Teo’s sits in that mix without trying to be a destination restaurant. You come for the dough, stay for the garden, and leave with the sense that the same people will still be there next Tuesday. The Malvern sister site on Malvern Road gives the group a second postcode; Highett is still the one with the parklet, the pool table and the weekend lunch service from midday.

If you are writing a night around it: arrive for Happy Hour, share arancini and calamari, split a Piccante and a Pumpkin or Matteo’s Special, and finish with tiramisu or a Nutella pizza if the table still has room. Wear the comfy pants.

 

 

Visit Teo’s Pizza & Bar, Highett

Address: 6 Railway Parade, Highett VIC 3190
Phone: (03) 9555 8812
Email: hello@matteospizzaparlour.com.au
Website: https://www.teospizza.com.au/
Highett page & menu PDF: https://www.teospizza.com.au/highett
Menu (PDF): https://www.teospizza.com.au/s/Highett_menu_a3-web.pdf
Order online: https://teospizza.orderup.com.au
Book a table: OpenTable — Teo’s Pizza & Bar Highett
Instagram: @teospizzabar

Hours (as published on the restaurant’s Highett page):
Tuesday–Friday: 4.30 pm until late
Weekends: midday until late (lunch from 12pm)
Closed Monday

Listings elsewhere sometimes show slightly earlier closing times midweek, so confirm on Instagram or by phone before you travel. Street parking; Highett Station is a short walk. Dine-in, pick-up and delivery. Functions by enquiry.

SHOUT US A COFFEE

If you like our work, why not shout us a coffee? Every contribution allows us to continue to serve local businesses, local sports clubs, and local community groups. It also helps us get kids into positive and healthy junior sport through our parent company BMBA Basketball Pty Ltd, where all funds are directed.

Support us so we can support our local communities. Buy us a coffee today!

The Community Forum – Our Services for your business

Website

Design

Social Media

Sales Funnel

Landing Pages

Email Marketing

Feature Articles

Video Promos

Your Page

Advertising