Einstein's 251, Caulfield North: Melbourne Brunch With a Middle Eastern Soul

At 251 Hawthorn Road in Caulfield North, Einstein's 251 sums itself up in a single line: “Melbourne coffee ritual. Middle Eastern soul.” Its own description is “Melbourne brunch with a Middle Eastern soul. Pull up a chair, order your usual, or discover a new favourite in our leafy courtyard.”

A playful name, a serious coffee habit

The café explains that it is “named in playful tribute to Albert Einstein”, and celebrates “inquisitive minds, shared tables, and clever recipes”. Its tagline, “Good food. Brilliant coffee. Pure genius.”, keeps the joke going, and the café quotes Einstein himself: “Life is like riding a bicycle. To keep your balance, you must keep moving.” Einstein's adds its own line: “And never skip your morning coffee.”

The coffee is taken seriously. The espresso bar opens at 7am on weekdays and describes its espresso as “balanced, full-bodied extraction with notes of rich roasted cocoa and warm hazelnut”, poured with silky microfoam. For warmer days there is slow-steeped cold brew, iced long blacks and iced lattes, made, as the café puts it, “for warm Melbourne afternoons under the courtyard canopy.”

The drinks list is broad. Alongside cappuccinos, lattes and flat whites, there are piccolos, short and long macs and the magic, which the café describes as "Melbourne's signature double ristretto with three-quarter textured milk". There is also batch brew filter coffee. For non-coffee drinkers, there are matcha, turmeric and chai lattes, with chai available in three styles, and loose-leaf teas from fresh mint to lemongrass and ginger. Milkshakes, smoothies and shakes include a peanut and Nutella milkshake and a banana and honey shake. Orange juice and a "super juice" blend are squeezed to order, from what the café says is Victorian produce.

Two kitchens in one

The Einstein's way, according to the café, brings “Melbourne's obsession with specialty brunch together with the deep, aromatic warmth of Middle Eastern home kitchens.” That shows on the menu. A traditional Middle Eastern shakshuka comes with tomatoes, capsicum, coriander, feta, green harissa and za'atar with flatbread. A sabich-style pita packs crispy haloumi, egg, eggplant and turmeric mayo into fresh hearth pita.

The café also offers a vegan version of the shakshuka, swapping the eggs and feta for beans and spinach. The pita pockets include a falafel version with "our brilliant falafels", Middle Eastern pickles and herb tahini, and a chicken BLAT.

Alongside them sit Melbourne brunch favourites. There is a house-cured spiced pastrami Reuben on seeded sourdough, and a haloumi breakfast that pairs crispy haloumi and avocado with mint yoghurt, pomegranate and poached eggs. The Einstein's Burger is built on a house wagyu patty. The breakfast list runs from toast, porridge and omelettes to fritters, a smoked salmon florentine with beetroot hummus, and an English breakfast. There is also a protein breakfast with chicken and chorizo, and a "sizzling steak" of eye fillet with green peppercorn sauce.

Later in the day there are two salads with suitably scientific names. The Albert Salad comes with a choice of tuna, smoked salmon or chicken, and the Noble Prize (the menu's spelling) combines crispy haloumi and mushrooms cooked in teriyaki sauce with cashews. Other options include a steak sandwich, a breakfast sandwich and a "Hashy Burger" stacked with two hash browns. For something sweet there are churros with strawberries and chocolate sauce, a sizzling brownie, and organic açaí bowls. The café also advertises freshly baked bagels.

Children get their own Little Einstein's menu, with Vegemite and cheese soldiers, half serves of eggs on toast, pancakes or French toast, nuggets and a cheeseburger. In the afternoons, the café says, flatbreads come “straight from the oven”.

The courtyard

Behind the counter is a leafy courtyard, which the café's own site calls its secret courtyard. Einstein's invites customers to “step away from the bustle of Hawthorn Road and into our leafy, sun-drenched courtyard. A sheltered Melbourne haven for long weekend catch-ups, another round of espresso, and absolutely no rush.” Courtyard tables can be booked by phone or email.

For those in a hurry, there is window takeaway, and orders can be phoned or texted ahead for a quick pick-up. The café also takes enquiries for private catering.

Why locals come back

According to local reviews, the draw is friendly staff and good coffee, and the shakshuka, omelettes and falafel pita are singled out. Ratings across the main review sites are solidly positive. The criticisms are that the café can get busy and a little cramped at peak times, and that service is occasionally inconsistent.

A stop on the 64

Einstein's sits right on the Route 64 tram line, at Stop 51, and pitches itself to commuters grabbing coffee “before boarding the Route 64 tram”. It opens at 7am on weekdays and 8am on weekends, closing mid-afternoon, and the kitchen closes 30 minutes before the café. The café calls itself “a community anchor built on hospitality”, and its promise to customers is simple: “you're always family here.”

Visit Einstein's 251
Address: 251 Hawthorn Road, Caulfield North VIC 3161
Phone: (03) 9939 5135 (SMS orders: 0450 065 143)
Hours: Monday to Friday 7am–3pm, Saturday and Sunday 8am–2:30pm; kitchen closes 30 minutes before close
Website: einsteins251.com.au
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/einsteins251/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/einsteins251/
Bookings: By phone (email details on the website), including courtyard reservations and private catering
Good to know: Window takeaway; Route 64 tram, Stop 51

SHOUT US A COFFEE

If you like our work, why not shout us a coffee? Every contribution allows us to continue to serve local businesses, local sports clubs, and local community groups. It also helps us get kids into positive and healthy junior sport through our parent company BMBA Basketball Pty Ltd, where all funds are directed.

Support us so we can support our local communities. Buy us a coffee today!

The Community Forum – Our Services for your business

Website

Design

Social Media

Sales Funnel

Landing Pages

Email Marketing

Feature Articles

Video Promos

Your Page

Advertising

About the Author

Noah Bennett
Noah Bennett covers local businesses and community groups across the City of Glen Eira for The Community Forum.